big fish.

jonah
i own one VeggieTales DVD.

it’s josh and the big wallbecause i like that the french peas of jericho attempt to deter the children of israel in this vegetarian interpretation of the conquest narrative with slushies.

i’ve always liked slushies.

i’ve always disliked peas.

i’m ambivalent about the french.

were i to buy another VeggieTales tale, it would most definitely be jonah – a VeggieTales movie, in part because of it’s interesting interpretation of the ‘wickedness’ of the people of nineveh. played, of course, by the french peas.

they slap each other with fishes.

what depravity.

the story of jonah is itself a biblical conundrum – one of those sections of scripture that may cause some more practical and scientific minds to question the accuracy, infallibility and authority of scripture.

‘really? a guy got swallowed by a giant fish, was puked up on shore and then started preaching?’

he must have smelled atrocious.

regardless of whether or not one is able to wrap their minds around a giant whale hosting the reluctant prophet of God for days on end before vomiting him onto the beach, the greater impossibility of the story of jonah is this ::

the wicked fish-slappers of nineveh repented.

and God forgave them.

that mere fact was too much for jonah to handle. he prayed to YHVH and said,

‘was this not what i said you would do?? this is why i tried to run away – because i knew that you are a gracious and compassionate God, slow to anger and abundant in hesed.’

the people of ninevah were among the most wicked of the ancient world – beyond just slapping one another with fish. they were cruel and intimidating, rebellious and defiant. as was common for nations in ancient near eastern culture, their treatment of conquered peoples, women and prisoners of war was anything but compassionate.

yet God was compassionate to them.

and jonah didn’t like it.

the story concludes with jonah brooding in a self-absorbed depression, even holding out hope that perhaps God would indeed destroy the city. he climbed up to a spot east of nineveh and waited to see what would happen.

in spite of God’s promise of peace, the pouting prophet hoped for punishment to those people.

combating compassion and fighting against divine grace, jonah in his narcissism reminded himself of their shortcomings. they were wicked. they were gentiles. they deserved judgement.

surely God’s righteousness wouldn’t be overshadowed by his grace?

in the story, YHVH converses with jonah and justifies his showing love and concern for even the people of nineveh. he asks a rhetorical question to the angry prophet, but there is no answer. the story stops there.

the sacred text ends the tale abruptly, its author employing a literary device at its conclusion that leaves the reader wondering whether jonah ‘got it’ or not.

for us, the question is :: do we?

what do you think?

  • tommy

    Was John Walton still teaching at Moody when you were there? He wrote a commentary on Jonah and I had him for Minor Prophets. His contention is that the people did not repent but I can’t remember how he gets around Jesus’ statement that they did? Oh well, Some folks, like Jonah, just cannot appreciate the grace of God. They would rather hate than love those whom He loves. Well done, MK.

    • http://www.mjkimpan.com/ michael j. kimpan

      he was. i quite honestly like his (un)traditional take on the (un)repentance of the people of nineveh. it seems to me that this best reflects God’s grace, which is defined (according to our profs at moody) as ‘unmerited favor.’ if we are asking for forgiveness, at least in some small way, we ‘deserve’ it – or at the very least, the forgiveness is dependent upon our action. the same could be said, some have suggested, with the contemporary notion of forgiveness in salvation as it relates to grace.

      what do you think?

      • tommy

        I think the moment we deserve anything it ceases to be a gift and becomes a wage instead. Salvation is a gift. Faith is a gift. Every week I end my message with a prayer that someone receives the gift of faith and thus be freed.

  • http://www.facebook.com/awcho70 Albert Cho

    Jonah’s story is a great allegory for us and the Church, both…

    For us, because it asks who are the Ninevites in our lives? Despite our best efforts, if we are honest with ourselves, we harbor unloving thoughts towards SOMEONE in our lives; but are they not our Ninevites? And as you ask at the end of your post, if we look at our behavior towards them, are we so different from Jonah?

    And the Church, because it so parallels what some churches still do to this day: turning away people who don’t fit their vision of who they want as part of their congregation. Thousands of years may have passed, but humans will be humans.

    Thank you, Michael, for a candid dissection of the book of Jonah (and VeggieTales).

    • http://www.mjkimpan.com/ michael j. kimpan

      absolutely on point observation, albert.

      thanks for reading!